mcgeady v strachan

[davieboy.rfc]

mcgeady has been fined 2 weeks wages & told he wont be playin first team football for 2 weeks ie missin the gers match after what happened 2 riordan ,aidan mcgeady should hav been advised 2 keep his mouth shu,t & not have a go at the manager, lets see if he is still at celtic by the end of the window.

[lfc4life]

He should leave and go too a club that will treat him better! Cause celtic haven't got a clue

[chunder]

He should leave and go too a club that will treat him better! Cause celtic haven't got a clue

That is a rather sweeping statement, lfc. I would be interested to know just how you have reached that conclusion and in what context you make such abold assertion. As far as it goes, Strachan - like every other manager - cannot allow his authority to be undermined. Shankly would never have let that happen. Nor Clough, and definitely not Ferguson. And I fancy Walter Smith would not put up with it either or Martin O'Neill. If McGeady had an issue with Strachan he should have sought to speak with him in private as opposed to telling him in the dressing room that he was an a***hole. The issue is that McGeady did not agree Strachan's tactical decision to have him play wide and stretch the Hearts defence.

IN much the same way that Keane was out of order in his debacle at Taipan, McGeady is another example of overpaid tossers getting ahead of themselves. In any other work environment his behaviour would result in dismissal for gross misconduct. I trust the same will happen at Parkhead.

[lfc4life]

well its a players right to be able too question his manager if he feels its not right! Then its upto the manager to explain why he is right!!!! You understand?

[chunder]

well its a players right to be able too question his manager if he feels its not right! Then its upto the manager to explain why he is right!!!! You understand?

Ah yes. You are, of course, referring to the Graham Souness textbook on football/ man management. Like the man says, there's a time and a place for everything and calling your gaffer an a***hole should not be done - if at all - outside of a private discussion. Assuming you have a job, why not try it tomorrow with your gaffer, eh? I guarantee your arse will be out the door quicker than Benitez asking for a raise.

So, what about the invitation to elaborate on your view that Celtic "haven't got a clue" ?

Love your innovative use of the smilies, btw.

[Knockoff_Nigel]

That is a rather sweeping statement, lfc. I would be interested to know just how you have reached that conclusion and in what context you make such abold assertion. As far as it goes, Strachan - like every other manager - cannot allow his authority to be undermined. Shankly would never have let that happen. Nor Clough, and definitely not Ferguson. And I fancy Walter Smith would not put up with it either or Martin O'Neill. If McGeady had an issue with Strachan he should have sought to speak with him in private as opposed to telling him in the dressing room that he was an a***hole. The issue is that McGeady did not agree Strachan's tactical decision to have him play wide and stretch the Hearts defence.

IN much the same way that Keane was out of order in his debacle at Taipan, McGeady is another example of overpaid tossers getting ahead of themselves. In any other work environment his behaviour would result in dismissal for gross misconduct. I trust the same will happen at Parkhead.

So Celtic will sack McGready for Gross Misconduct and watch as ?25million worth of talent walks away.

[Knockoff_Nigel]

Ooops I missed the decimal point in ?25 million

[lfc4life]

me thinks there will dump him in the reserves till he says sorry!

[chunder]

More likely that he will go in the January window. Win-win that way. McGeady gets away, Celtic get a few quid.

[lfc4life]

But who will take a player that lacks respect for there manager?

[chunder]

Why don't you have a word with Rafa; from what you say it seems like being a team p[layer is not high on the list of LFC priorities.

[lfc4life]

Why don't you have a word with Rafa; from what you say it seems like being a team p[layer is not high on the list of LFC priorities.

this is true! om happy we are top of the league. Bit he is going to come unstuck! if he keeps meddling

[ootmaroad]

wee huffybaws....Greedy McGeady... can fek off....

.. if it wasn't for Strachan he would not have won, player of the year last year... okay he is a good player, has a lot of potential, but he aint no superstar...

...wee Mizuno took mcgeady's place with ease today and looks to be as good as Mcgeady on his day.... or even much better..

you cannot call your manager an arsehole in front of the full squad unless you believe in your little mind that you are in such a needed position to do so... the manager would have lost all respect from the other players....who may think they can call him an arsehole too .... the board backed Strachan after wee moody baws complained to the highest..... the board knew if they never backed Strachan then the wee man would have been quick enough to stick the job up their arse.... Strachan would break the patience of a saint with his stubborness but i'd rather have him at the steering wheel, than greedy mcgeady on the wing....

He's lucky, other managers would have just hit him a few slaps in front of the whole team and left him to make a quiet exit.....

no player is bigger than any club...... well except for Fergusson at Rangers... although it makes you wonder where Rangers would be today if PLG had been given a few years... don't get me wrong wee BF is a true captain at rangers.. but he too aint no Ronaldo....


PS Maloney and McGeady are decent players but they are not the best players at Celtic...
Always looking forward to Brown v Fergusson..

[ootmaroad]

He should leave and go too a club that will treat him better! Cause celtic haven't got a clue

you havent a clue yafudd..

[gazz]

He should leave and go too a club that will treat him better! Cause celtic haven't got a clue

forget about gree n' blue its f'ball