man utd all time 11

[cantona7]

have not got my all time 11 sorted yet but will do tonite /tomorrow

rules are pick your favourite/best utd team from any era and place in a squad of 11 with 5 subs.
sounds easy but there are so many to choose from its hard to know who to put in and at the expense of who !!!
and to keep every one happy in 1 week we will do another team then another and so on.
get thinking footy fans

[aftermath]

I wrote these few down first , then tried to break the list down to 11 players and 5 subs,, I found it very hard and i bet i missed someone out...

Cristiano Ronaldo
George Best
Ryan Giggs
Sir Bobby Charlton
Paul Scholes
Dennis Law
Gary Neville
Duncan Edwards
David Beckham
Denis Irwin
Reo Ferdinand
Bill Foulkes
Ole Solskjaer
Roy Keane
Ruud Van Nistelrooy
Eric Cantona
Dennis Viollet
Gary Pallister
Peter Schmicheal
Steve Bruce
Bryan Robson
Mark Hughes
Alex Stepney
Jack Rowley
David Beckham
Patrice Evra
Wayne Rooney
Nemanja Vidic
Kevin Moran


My all time Utd Team


1. Peter Schmeichael
2. Denis irwin
3. Gary Neville
4. Bryan Robson
5. Kevin Moran
6. Roy Keane
7. Christiano Ronaldo
8. Paul Scoles
9. George best
10 King Eric
11 Ryan Giggs



subs

Rio Ferdinand
Nemanja Vidic
David Beckham
Ruud van Nistleruuy
Dennis Law

[young]

well after much debating heres mine

1.Schmeichel
2.Pallister
3.G. Neville
4.Rio Ferdinand
5.Jaap Stam
6.Riyan Giggs
7.George Best
8.Paul Scholes
9.Eric Cantona
10.Wayne Rooney
11.Ole Gunnar Solskj?r

Subs
David Beckham
Teddy Sheringham
Sir bobby Charlton
Roy Keane
Steve Bruce

the list could go on and on

[steppenwolf]

e=mc2, I think this is easier to do...

1. Peter Schmaechael
2. Denis Irwin
3. Gary Neville
4. Nemanja Vidic
5. Rio Ferdinand
6. Roy Keane
7. Paul Scholes
8. Ryan Giggs
9. Ronaldo
10. Rooney
11. Cantona

subs:

George Best
Sir Bobby Charlton
Gary Pallister
Jaap Stam
David Beckham

uh very hard

[thered]

e=mc2, I think this is easier to do...

1. Peter Schmaechael
2. Denis Irwin
3. Gary Neville
4. Nemanja Vidic
5. Rio Ferdinand
6. Roy Keane
7. Paul Scholes
8. Ryan Giggs
9. Ronaldo
10. Rooney
11. Cantona

subs:

George Best
Sir Bobby Charlton
Gary Pallister
Jaap Stam
David Beckham

uh very hard

only team in my opinion to so far to resemble a correct looking formation 4-4-2 one thing everyone will definately aggree on is big schmike at no.1

however although irwin was mr dependable he is not in evra's league for left back almost everyone else i agree with though although i find it hard not too have bryan robson in the squad and ruud van nistelrooy

one thing i will say is im not old enough to have seen best or charlton play so i cant really put them in clips on the tv do not give a full picture so here is my squad of 16 in a 4-4-2

1. P Schemiechel
2. G Neville
3. P Evra
4. J Stam
5. R Ferdinand
6. R Keane
7. P Scholes
8. R Giggs
9. C Ronaldo
10 E Cantona
11 R V Nistelrooy

Subs ...

12 G Pallister
13 B Robson
14 M Hughes
15 W Rooney

16 i cant pick i have about 5 for a place in the squad

its hard being a manager

[opsmonkey]

not to cause a headache to you all but..

Surely a Man Utd side that (baring a miracle and please god be there one) is about to win its 3rd back to back League title and potentailly be the first in history to retain the Champions Legaue trophy, must be considered the best all time 11....????

[alker ranger]

schmeichel
neville stam vidic evra

ronaldo scholes robson (c) giggs

rooney van nistlerooy

van der sar
ferdinand
beckham
keane
cantona

it was a toss up between ronaldo and beckham but how can you leave out a fifa world player of the year?

[maca]

im surprised duncan edwards has only been mentioned once. not that i know to mutch about him, but according to my dad he was one hell of a player

[Ballistic]

This Guys some my thoughts and team pretty well All-Time Line Up: Manchester United | Bleacher Report

Mentions of the likes of Martin Buchan, Dennis Law,Roger Byrne, Charlton and Edwards...Got the likes of Stapleton too who i remember well.

Anyone read Bobby Charltons Bio, its a real good read and would recommend it to any Football fan.

So if I would have to pick one to watch it would be.

................................Schmeichel........ ...................

.....Irwin...........Bruce.........Buchan......... ..Edwards...

...Giggs...........Charlton......Keane.....Ronaldo ......

...............KING E.........Law.................

Subs

Scholes
Beckham
Nistelroy
Best
Foulkes
Robson

Stepney

[steppenwolf]

First of all, CONGRATULATIONS TO NEMANJA VIDIC for wining two individual titles from the UTD players, and from UTD fans. In my opinion he should won the title of the best player in Premier League this season (Giggs agreed), and the true red Gerrad sad that he hates UTD but that Nemanja deserved the reward for being outstandig this sesason... But everyone like strikers and "joke" players...

TOP MAN UTD PLAYERS IN LAST 23 YEARS by "the SUN"

P.Schmeichel

G.Neville R.Ferdinand N.Vidic D.Irwin

C. Ronaldo P. Scholes R. Keane R. Giiggs

E. Cantona R. Van Nistelrooy

[footycard steve]

im surprised duncan edwards has only been mentioned once. not that i know to mutch about him, but according to my dad he was one hell of a player

very good point always mentioned by older players as the best of his era maybe most members are too young to know how good he was or would have been.