Why shat navs can lead to your death

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • gmb45
    Admin Assistant
    • Nov 2008
    • 7538

    #1

    Why shat navs can lead to your death

    Sat nav ... useful, but could it prove deadly?

    NEARLY half of us own one, around three million are sold each year - but satellite navigation systems should be used with extreme caution.

    For the seemingly handy device in your car could be a killer.

    On Wednesday The Sun told the tragic story of motorist Rachel Edwards who was forced to choose between saving the life of her two-year-old daughter or son aged 16.

    Rachel's Citroen Xsara crashed into a 15ft wide drainage ditch near Mablethorpe, Lincs.

    An inquest heard her sat nav had guided her on to a series of increasingly minor roads - including a dead end - before the tragedy.


    Son Jack was trapped inside and drowned while pregnant Rachel struggled to free little Isabella.

    At the inquest coroner Paul Smith said: "It is questionable for any system to divert traffic away from an arterial route on to a B road then a C road which is little more than a farm track."

    While it had the most dire of consequences Rachel's case is not an isolated incident.

    Sat navs frequently send motorists the wrong direction. Even so, they are more popular than ever, with 49 per cent of Brits owning one.

    These days it doesn't cost a fortune to have one in your car.

    Entry level devices cost just ?50 and a free sat nav iPhone app by firm Skobbler was downloaded more than 70,000 times in the first few weeks of its launch last year.

    Experts believe people are losing vital map-reading skills because they have become so dependent on technology.

    Despite that, many people have their own navigation aid horror stories.

    So before you make your next journey take a look at these sat nav nightmares.


    Last year 17-year-old Natasha Paton was killed when a coach carrying 39 school kids home from Alton Towers crashed in a blizzard in Lanarkshire.

    It is believed the driver took a longer route and an arguably more dangerous road unsuitable for a bus because of instructions from his sat nav.
    Tragic ... Lanarkshire bus

    Ariana Bardhaj, four, from Blackpool, was killed last year when her learner driver dad took an illegal right turn into oncoming traffic.

    He had been incorrectly instructed to do this by his sat nav on the A6 near Bolton, Greater Manchester.
    Fatal error ... Ariana's dad took wrong turn after instruction from his sat nav

    Promising sportswoman Rhiannon Lawrence from Plymouth, Devon, nearly died in a pile-up involving a lorry after she did a U-turn when the sat nav misdirected her.

    The international fencer was taken off at the wrong junction on the A30 at Journey's End, near Truro, Cornwall, last year.

    She was in a coma for 17 days but thankfully recovered.
    Floody brilliant ... rescue after van took a very wrong turn

    In 2008 four members of a theatre company had to be rescued from the roof of their pink Mercedes van after their sat nav directed them through a flooded river in Gillingham, Dorset.

    The fire and rescue service used ladders to help down the stricken group who were in danger of being swept away by the torrent.
    Slack nav ... warning on Lincolnshire road

    Three pensioners were stranded for four hours last year after the private ambulance they were travelling in crashed thanks to the sat nav.

    The device instructed the driver down back roads completely unsuitable for the freezing conditions.

    The vehicle slid on ice and crashed into a ditch near Duloe, Cornwall.

    Rescue services were unable to reach the stranded pensioners for four hours as the country lanes were impassable.
    Wreck ... four-year-old Ariana Bardhaj was killed in smash

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Why sat nav can lead to your death | The Sun |Features
    Last edited by gmb45; 22 April, 2011, 06:44.
    support mountain resue

    support digital-kaos here


    forum rules

    no keygens or torrents to be posted no autodata discussions

    pish pt walkers


  • Shady
    Shite Link King
    • Dec 2010
    • 6404

    #2
    sat navs have been sending people the wrong way since they came out...must be a slow news day for the scum to bring this up again
    Fave replies from various threads

    1: What the fff is all that about??? All that crap below your reply I mean, get a life mate
    2: no info on google abt the pace sv5 rang asda they have no idea what i was talking about,
    3: Your total contribution to this forum, bordering on trolling, seems to have been a collection of snipes, one liners & asterisked expletives





    Comment

    • gopher7
      DK Veteran
      • Apr 2011
      • 2818

      #3
      sat nav's are dangerous, bin yours and learn to read a map before your killed.

      Comment

      • barrowmanandrew
        V.I.P. Member
        • Nov 2009
        • 3427

        #4
        Originally posted by gopher7
        sat nav's are dangerous, bin yours and learn to read a map before your killed.
        not so sure about that tbh,

        peeps could easily get confused with a map too and be left dithering at a complex junction.
        and its easier to glance at a sat nav whilst driving than have a quick look at a map.

        beside, maps have mistakes and go out of date just the same as sat navs do.

        as Jok said,
        used sensibly its a great driving aid, has to used with common sense though

        Comment

        • oneman
          DK Veteran
          • Mar 2011
          • 307

          #5
          Originally posted by gmb45
          In 2008 four members of a theatre company had to be rescued from the roof of their pink Mercedes van after their sat nav directed them through a flooded river in Gillingham, Dorset.

          The fire and rescue service used ladders to help down the stricken group who were in danger of being swept away by the torrent.
          Originally posted by gmb45
          Three pensioners were stranded for four hours last year after the private ambulance they were travelling in crashed thanks to the sat nav.

          The device instructed the driver down back roads completely unsuitable for the freezing conditions.
          So basically two example of where sat nav was correct in chosing the road but road was made difficult to use due to weather conditions. AFAIK, no satnav includes road condition information based on weather ?

          Comment

          • drawflex
            DK Veteran
            • Dec 2008
            • 440

            #6
            much of london is red-routed and many roads don't permit you to stop or pull-over in order to read map, it only takes a few seconds and you get a nice fine sent out automatically.. driving whilst trying to follow a map spread out on your lap is more dangerous than following a decent, up to-date sat-nav.. and you can keep eyes on the road because I got a bird telling me in advance where to go, and what lane... you can spot a map-reading driver easily, by his last min turn-offs and lane changes, and always slowing down at every junction to read road names
            'He's not the messiah, he's a very naughty boy'.

            Comment

            • Canker_Canison
              V.I.P. Member
              • May 2010
              • 3905

              #7
              Experts believe people are losing vital map-reading skills because they have become so dependent on technology.
              A vast majority of drivers wouldn't know what to do with a map. What's lacking is common sense.

              Ariana Bardhaj, four, from Blackpool, was killed last year when her learner driver dad took an illegal right turn into oncoming traffic.

              He had been incorrectly instructed to do this by his sat nav on the A6 near Bolton, Greater Manchester.
              Where the ~~~~ was his qualified passenger! Learner drivers have to be accompanied by a qualified driver over the age of 21 with a minimum of 3 years driving experience.

              All of these stories involve idiots who probably deserve to die. People that thick shouldn't be allowed behind the wheel. It's just a shame they take innocent people with them.
              Canker

              "Animal, vegetable or mineral... I'll do anything, to anything, with anything"
              - The Baby Eating Bishop of Bath & Wells
              [COLOR=Green]

              Comment

              • SouthernComfort
                DK Veteran
                • Feb 2011
                • 403

                #8
                Natural Selection springs to mind, a sat nav is a guide.
                "What we've got here is failure to communicate."

                Comment

                • masur123
                  DK Veteran
                  • Aug 2009
                  • 674

                  #9
                  Sat navs are a wonderful invention, bu t surely common sense must prevail. Yes they can often lead you the worng way, but any driver must make the common sense decision before following any instruction.
                  Most sat navs have routing decisions before calculating route, I often find that Optimised will take you through all the back roads, whislt fastest will take you via M/A roads.

                  In all the instances above I can only assume there were no roads signs indicating the dangers ahead as well.....

                  Comment

                  • SouthernComfort
                    DK Veteran
                    • Feb 2011
                    • 403

                    #10
                    If you don't have the mental capacity to tell the difference between a river and a road maybe you shouldn't be operating a 1 tonne+ machine. For my safety though not yours.
                    My heart goes out to the innocent victims.
                    Last edited by SouthernComfort; 22 April, 2011, 17:46.
                    "What we've got here is failure to communicate."

                    Comment

                    • drawflex
                      DK Veteran
                      • Dec 2008
                      • 440

                      #11
                      Originally posted by SouthernComfort
                      Natural Selection springs to mind, a sat nav is a guide.
                      yeh, something tells that the sort of person that ends up with a car in a ditch 'because tomtom said so', might run into other problems where basic common sence is required.. but sadly us humans seem to have evolved past natural selection.. and any ignorant dimwit can get a driving lisence (obviously).
                      'He's not the messiah, he's a very naughty boy'.

                      Comment

                      • badapple
                        V.I.P. Member
                        • Dec 2008
                        • 2041

                        #12
                        Despite the few horror stories, there are THOUSANDS of success stories in using a sat nat to get you from A 2 B.

                        Me & all my drivers have a sat nav (this is my company rule)
                        and tbh we would now not cope without this genius device, especially if you drive long distances across the country.

                        We have driven the whole of the UK using these devices and never encountered any problems.

                        Sound advise is to "KEEP YOUR SAT NAV UPDATED TO THE LATEST MAPS & SAFETY CAMERAS".

                        But as always with using these devices the driver should use common sense!

                        Only a dumb lorry/coach driver will leave a main road and take a farm/dirt track!!!
                        SLOWLY, OUR FREEDOM IS BEING ERASED.
                        SOON, WE WILL JUST BE A NUMBER.
                        IF WE DON'T FOLLOW, WE WILL BE ERASED.

                        Comment

                        • lee_hdi
                          DK Veteran
                          • Oct 2009
                          • 928

                          #13
                          Sat Nav's are perfectly fine, as they are just a guide. It's just people use them and seem to lose all common sense and listen to them rather than looking at the road.
                          Don't let failure go to your heart, don't let success go to your head.

                          Comment

                          • Snowy79
                            DK Veteran
                            • Jan 2011
                            • 1347

                            #14
                            Got to agree, when I learnt to drive you were tested to the standards of the Highway code and taught to look at the road ahead if you can't follow road signs or see what's ahead of you it's time to take a bus.

                            Comment

                            • SouthernComfort
                              DK Veteran
                              • Feb 2011
                              • 403

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Snowy79
                              Got to agree, when I learnt to drive you were tested to the standards of the Highway code and taught to look at the road ahead if you can't follow road signs or see what's ahead of you it's time to take a bus.
                              Would be safer giving some people a loaded weapon and a blindfold.
                              "What we've got here is failure to communicate."

                              Comment

                              Working...