In the document the squad was valued and categorised into recommendations to either be 'retained', 'sold' or 'monitored,' and Carroll, who netted 11 goals for Newcastle in their return to Premier League before his deadline-day switch, was grouped into the latter.
As it turned out Carroll became a key part of Newcastle's romp back to the top flight, scoring 17 goals in the Championship.
Kop ambition: Andy Carroll will be hoping to make his Liverpool debut against Man United
Reds boss Kenny Dalglish moved swiftly to seal the signing of 22-year-old after Fernando Torres joined Chelsea for ?50m, completing Carroll's transition from Championship player to British record signing in just 18 months.
'There were soundings taken around the club about how players should be valued and there was a feeling Andy still had to prove himself,' a Newcastle source told The Sun.
'He was a young lad who wasn***8217;t established in the first team and he had limited experience in the Premier League.
'It was a case of seeing how he got on at the start of last season.
'Andy did really well and started scoring plenty of goals.
'But if anyone had come in with a ?1m offer that summer you wonder what the club would have done.'
heres the relevant part of the alleged insider report WERE in this article does it state that andy carroll WOULD have been sold for 1 million, massaging an article to suit your own purposes doesen't work does it ?look at the catergories which one is he in its not the SOLD is it if your going to come on here posting shite be able to back it up (sorry andy you just can't help posting shite can you) you seem to have an unhealthy agenda against kenny dalglish hmmmm i wonder why
As it turned out Carroll became a key part of Newcastle's romp back to the top flight, scoring 17 goals in the Championship.
Kop ambition: Andy Carroll will be hoping to make his Liverpool debut against Man United
Reds boss Kenny Dalglish moved swiftly to seal the signing of 22-year-old after Fernando Torres joined Chelsea for ?50m, completing Carroll's transition from Championship player to British record signing in just 18 months.
'There were soundings taken around the club about how players should be valued and there was a feeling Andy still had to prove himself,' a Newcastle source told The Sun.
'He was a young lad who wasn***8217;t established in the first team and he had limited experience in the Premier League.
'It was a case of seeing how he got on at the start of last season.
'Andy did really well and started scoring plenty of goals.
'But if anyone had come in with a ?1m offer that summer you wonder what the club would have done.'
heres the relevant part of the alleged insider report WERE in this article does it state that andy carroll WOULD have been sold for 1 million, massaging an article to suit your own purposes doesen't work does it ?look at the catergories which one is he in its not the SOLD is it if your going to come on here posting shite be able to back it up (sorry andy you just can't help posting shite can you) you seem to have an unhealthy agenda against kenny dalglish hmmmm i wonder why
Sir Alex Ferguson. 
(20)
one of the biggest forums on the internet and you think you've given it "much needed life" 
Comment